UpOnly LearningHomeschool guide

How to choose a homeschool curriculum: an honest guide

There is no single best homeschool curriculum. There is the one that fits your student, your time, your budget and your home language. This guide helps you find it, including when the honest answer is a program other than ours.

By Dr. Evan J. Hasson, Founder, UpOnly Learning · Last checked:

Text WhatsApp

Quick answer: Decide who teaches and for how long each day, set a budget, pick your home language and whether you want secular or faith-based lessons. Then compare types, look at samples and the full topic list, and try one subject for two weeks before buying a full year.

Start with five questions

  1. Who teaches, and for how long each day? A parent with two hours a day needs something different from one with forty minutes. Scripted lessons save you planning time; open-ended programs ask more of you.
  2. What is your budget for the year? It ranges from free to several hundred dollars per student. Decide before you shop.
  3. What language does your family learn in? If you speak Spanish or Portuguese at home, most programs are English only. UpOnly Learning teaches every subject in all three.
  4. Secular or faith-based? Many popular programs include faith content. Decide which you want, and check samples.
  5. Where is your student now? Reading level, attention span and gaps matter more than age. Take the free placement test first.

Every type of curriculum, compared

TypeWhat it isGood forWatch out forTypical cost
Boxed, all in oneA full year of every subject from one publisher, often shipped as books.Parents who want every decision made.Paying for subjects your student does not need at that level.High
Mix and matchYou choose a different program for each subject.Students ahead in one subject and behind in another.More planning, and gaps between programs.Low to high
Scripted lessonsEach lesson tells you what to say and do, in order.New homeschoolers and busy parents.Less room for your own style, unless you adapt it.Low to medium
Online or videoA teacher on screen teaches; the student works on a device.Parents with little time to teach.Screen time, and less of you in the lesson.Medium to high
Literature-basedLearning through real books and narration.Families who love reading together.Math and grammar usually need a separate program.Low to medium
Unit studiesSeveral subjects taught around one theme.Teaching several ages together.Skills like math still need their own sequence.Low to medium
Free and libraryFree websites, library books and printables.Tight budgets, or filling one gap.You do the sequencing and checking yourself.Free

Many families end up mixing: one program for math, another for reading, and a unit study or read-alouds for science and history. That is normal.

A note on learning styles

You will read that you should match lessons to a visual, auditory or hands-on learner. Researchers who reviewed the evidence found little support for that idea (Pashler and colleagues, 2008). What does have strong evidence: practicing recall instead of rereading, and spacing practice over several days (Dunlosky and colleagues, 2013). Choose a curriculum that builds those in, and use what your student enjoys to keep them motivated.

Red flags before you buy

  • No sample of a full lesson to look at.
  • No list of every topic in the year (a scope and sequence).
  • No answer keys, or answers sold separately at a high price.
  • A subscription that is hard to pause or cancel.
  • Promises of guaranteed results or grade levels gained.

What a topic list should look like: What is a scope and sequence?

Try it before you commit

  1. Read the free sample of one full topic.
  2. Teach it for two weeks, one subject only.
  3. Ask: did my student learn it, and could I teach it without dread?
  4. If yes, add the next subject. If not, try a different type.

Where UpOnly Learning fits, and where it does not

A good fit if you want scripted lessons you can teach without planning, every subject from kindergarten to 8th grade plus high school courses, the same lessons in English, Spanish and Portuguese, and printable workbooks with full answer keys.

Probably not the right fit if you want faith-based lessons (UpOnly Learning is secular), a live teacher on video, or a school that awards grades and a diploma (UpOnly Learning is a publisher, not an accredited school).

See the plans side by side: UpOnly Learning plans compared

Questions parents ask

What is the best homeschool curriculum?

There is no single best one. The best curriculum is the one your student learns from and you can teach consistently. Use the five questions above, look at samples, and test one subject before buying a year.

Should I buy a full boxed curriculum for my first year?

Not necessarily. Many families start with math and reading only, add subjects after a few weeks, and avoid paying for a full box they do not use.

Can I switch curriculum mid-year?

Yes. If something is not working after a fair try, switching is normal. Take the placement test again so you start the new program at the right level.

Do I need a curriculum for kindergarten?

Many families keep kindergarten light: read-alouds, letter sounds, counting and play. A simple program for reading and math helps keep it steady.

A guide, not legal advice. Homeschool rules are set by each state and can change. Always confirm the current rules with your state's education department or the official sources in your state guide.

Text WhatsApp

UpOnly Learning is a private educational publisher, not a school. We award no grades, credits or diplomas, we are not accredited, and nothing we publish satisfies a legal requirement on its own.

Each topic names the standard it addresses. That alignment is UpOnly Learning's own reading of the published standards; the people who own those standards do not review or endorse what we publish, and standards change.